HEAD-TO-HEAD COMPARISON
#27
#1
#27
#1
12
22
0
3
57.5
30.8
23
32
The Horse Whisperer $75.4 Million
Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest $423.3 Million
$528.6 Million
Box Office
$1.8 Billion
COMMUNITY VOTE
Who had the greater Hollywood career overall?
Cast your vote and compare your opinion with the community.
✓ Thanks for voting!
0 community votes
Community voting reflects visitor opinion and is independent of the Hollywood Rankings methodology.
CAREER RANKING HISTORY
FILMOGRAPHY COMPARISON
Scarlett Johansson
23 theatrical releases • $528.6 Million Domestic
| Year | Movie | Domestic Box Office Domestic BO |
|---|---|---|
| 2006 | The Prestige | $53.1 Million |
| 2006 | The Black Dahlia | $22.5 Million |
| 2006 | Scoop | $10.5 Million |
| 2006 | A Good Woman | $238,609 |
| 2005 | The Island | $35.8 Million |
Johnny Depp
32 theatrical releases • $1.8 Billion Domestic
| Year | Movie | Domestic Box Office Domestic BO |
|---|---|---|
| 2006 | Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest | $423.3 Million |
| 2005 | The Libertine | $4.8 Million |
| 2005 | Corpse Bride | $53.4 Million |
| 2005 | Charlie and the Chocolate Factory | $206.5 Million |
| 2004 | Secret Window | $48.0 Million |
Career Comparison Summary AI-generated historical comparison. Click to expand.
Note: Films released during the selected year influence the following year's rankings.
By the 2006 season, the comparison is less about a single breakout moment and more about the shape of each actor's accumulated Hollywood results. Selected-year rank is the clearest ranking-side separator, with Johnny Depp holding the stronger position in this snapshot.
Career peak is the clearest ranking-side separator, with Johnny Depp holding the stronger position in this snapshot. From a historical perspective, the matchup leans toward Johnny Depp and remains tied to the selected ranking season.