By the 2026 season, the comparison is less about a single breakout moment and more about the shape of each actor's accumulated Hollywood results. The biggest-hit category sharpens the box office contrast, especially because Scarlett Johansson's leading film creates the stronger single-release benchmark.

Commercial scale is another meaningful divider, with the career domestic box office measure giving Scarlett Johansson the larger theatrical footprint. Based on the available ranking data, the balance leans toward Scarlett Johansson without turning the result into a subjective judgment of acting quality.